We came here for our 25th wedding anniversary and were seated at a beautiful seat overlooking the ocean. There was a really cute sign on our table lit up with lights that said "happy anniversary". Our food was delicious and our server was very personable. We had a great evening and celebration. We will definitely be back.

We had a fabulous dinner experience thanks to the creative and delicious food as well as service perfection from Andrea and her colleagues! The experience in terms of food & wine was comparable to Latitudes or A&B Lobster, but the service one-upped both of those experiences because our server took the time to engage with us during and after our meal to discuss the ingredients and preparation of our selections. The menu offered plenty of seafood options with a maybe just slightly Indian influence. Wine selections were very good; we went with a Chablis to accompany our entrees. We shared the lobster bisque for starters - fantastic with a unique cinnamon spiciness. For entrees we chose local pink shrimp dishes - one with grits, and one as a cavatappi-cheese entree. The decor of the dining room is low-lit, romantic, and quiet - perfect for couples or groups that want to converse and be heard. Highly recommend, with an added bonus of being able to walk back to the room when you're staying at Ocean Key!

Food,service, and view were incredible! The bar next door had an awful band howling Bob Marley songs that did ruin the experience. They played from 5-7, plan on going after but then you miss the sunset.

We had an excellent meal and superb service. Seating outside was lovely, and our servers were attentive and helpful with recommendations. We enjoyed the variety of small plates and shared an entree. Dessert was delicious.

I'm so glad I found this place! Tucked away in the back of the dock, you definitely need to know that this place exists to find it. It's above bar/restaurant that's on the dock. People recommended this place for brunch but we came here for dinner instead. The dinner was just as great and if you come at the right time you'll be able to see the sun set. Highly recommend a reservation if you're trying to catch the sunset. We didn't have one but we got here right as they open for dinner so got seated outside over looking the waters. The servers here are very nice. They are very attentive and provide excellent recommendations. I got the swordfish special of the day. It was my first time trying swordfish, and it was phenomenal. The firmness of the swordfish meat was well seasoned. The braised ribs were super yummy and tender. Highly recommend this place!

Great views of the western side of the island. Amazing service. I was able to get a reservation but they weren't busy at all. Food was pretty good. Price is high.

What an absolutely delightful 5-star experience. We actually made a reservation at another restaurant in the area and decided to come here instead. We were so grateful they were able to accommodate us as they usually require a reservation in advance. My fiancé and I were celebrating our 1-year anniversary and spending the weekend in town with great friends. From the beginning, the service was impeccable and the food was some of the best I've ever had out at a restaurant. I think we ordered 6 or 7 dishes and shared everything between the four of us, which was plenty of food and I loved being able to try so many things. The standouts to me were the heirloom tomato and burrata salad, the seared grouper, braised beef short rib, and wild mushrooms. They have a wonderful wine selection and from most seats in the restaurant, you can see a wonderful sunset. Hot Tin Roof is definitely a special occasion and romantic spot for dinner and I look forward to coming to visit again when we're in the area. 10/10 recommend!

Perfect meal Joanne did an amazing job, wish she could be my server for every meal Start to finish, everything was perfect.

I have nothing but good things to say about Hot Tin Roof. Service, food, drinks, the view... all excellent!! We went on a Friday, for early dinner. They had our table ready for us with a perfect view of the sunset. It was our anniversary and they had a sign for us to celebrate, and noted they did the same for other birthday tables. Great personal attention to the notes on the reservations. Out server was equally attentive. He made great recommendations, answered all questions we had about the menu and drinks, checked up on us to make sure we weren't missing anything and enjoying our time there... Just incredible service. And the food, wow!! I must call out one dish in particular. The Duck Confit was recommended by our server and so glad we listened. This was prepared perfectly. Crispy skin, tender juicy meat that fell off the bone and the cherry sauce complemented the tasted of the duck so well. And presentation was just beautiful. In addition to all the above, the sunset view is just breathtaking and so peaceful, it wrapped with a bow our experience there.

What a spot. We had plans to be in Key West for just a a night, so I wanted to get a pretty good sunset dinner spot. I talked to a few friends and such to see what is thought to be a good spot. Tin roof people said was a great spot. We got lucky due to a cancellation and got a spot 530pm. Amazing spot. I'll put one photo on here, but in person beats any pic. We got a series of small plates. The ciabatta, the lobster bisque, and the duck. The bisque was a little cold, the ciabatta was fine, and the duck was just fine. But my goodness, what a view. The view along with a good dinner was a highlight of key west. It's a spot that was the capstone of a nice weekend.